So if you live in certain parts of the US, you’re probably quite aware of the racism that still exists (at least in my opinion) of whites against blacks, blacks against Hispanics, Asians against blacks, Vietnamese against Koreans, etc. So you’re probably also not suprised then, when I say that there’s some centuries-old racism in Afghanistan as well.
There are lots of groups in Afghanistan. You’ve got Pashtuns (the predominant ethnicity of the Southern area of the country adjacent to Pakistan), Tajiks, some Uzbeks, some Turkmen, Hazara, etc. In the beginning I couldn’t tell the difference between them all, except for Hazaras, who look distinctly East “Asian.” Just like most of you guys out there, I was under the impression that all Afghans got the same look – they’re all brown people in a dusty place. Well of course, after a while, you get an acquaintance of the cultural/ethnic subtleties of the place, and realize that there are still some strong ethnic divisions in Afghanistan. Although most younger people all speak Dari, the common language, a lot of traditional families will have family members that speak only Tajik/Pashtun/Turkmen to each other.
And the divisions are more obvious with politics. That’s right, ethnic divisions and politics – make great fun – and fresh fodder for armed conflict. Which is why a lot of people are blaming Pashtuns for terrorist violence here. But you can’t totally blame the Pashtuns for the violence, of course. But the Afghan govt, for example does its daily dose on Pashtun finger-pointing by saying that Pakistan has turned a blind eye on all the Pashtun terrorist training camps on its territory, and has subsequently allowed those terrorists to cross over the border and do some harm to the Afghan/coalition authorities. But from a Pashtun point of view, you can’t really blame Pashtuns for everything.
(a brief history)—-
Not too long ago, Afghanistan and Pakistan were in one country…this is before modern “nation-states” existed. Pashtun people ruled, just as they have ruled the area…for a long time, Afghanistan served as a stronghold against the Hindu Indian incursions, which is why the mountains in Afghanistan are called the Hindu Kush (i.e. “the Hindu Killers”). That’s when the Mongols were still in charge here. But things changed, the Safavid and Mughal empires vied for territory, and Afghanistan (as well as Pakistan) was caught up in the middle, on the periphery of empires, as it had always been throughout history. Come now the British colonizers, and the take-over of India by the British empire. The British throw things into upheaval, try to take over Afghanistan as well (but succeed only in taking modern Pakistan/India/Bangladesh/etc instead), and the British (and Afghan king) intelligently decide to just draw borders of Afghanistan apart from that territory all together – in what became the “Durand Line,” splitting “Pashtunistan” down the middle. So now you have Afghanistan as its own territory, but the Pashtun people have been split – many are in Pakistan, and many are in southern Afghanistan, and they are the predominant ethnicity there! There are also a sizeable number of other central Asian ethnicities in southern Afghanistan, but the representation is much more noticeable in the north of the country, where Afghanistan borders Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, etc. And of course, Iran is directly to the West. And after a couple wars and de-colonization you start getting clamors for a “nation-state.” Pakistan becomes its own territory apart from India. Afghanistan is also in the process of forming its own nation-state, and so territorial conflicts and claims over Pashtun tribes erupt in armed advances over the blurry Afghan/Pakistan border. So later the Russians come in, screw things up some more, and then get kicked out by the Mujahedeen/Taliban. More war ensues, the Mujahed and Taliban duke it out, and aha! Taliban and their friend Osama bin Laden take over the government! Americans later come in and kick butt., then try invite international organizations like the UN and USAID to come in …And that’s the [exteremely] simplified history of Afghanistan…
—(brief history ends)
So today, you still have your political patronage based on ethnic lines. For example, President Karzai is Pashtun, but he tries his best to dole out cabinet positions to non-Pashtuns: several of the original were Hazaras (maybe too many), many were Tajiks, some were Uzbeks, etc. Some might call this “affirmitive action,” to have proportional ethnic representation in the executive government…but for Karzai it was just a politically intelligent positioning. But what happens if only mostly Tajiks and Pashtuns are the capable and educated candidates in these positions? Keep in mind that almost all educated Afghans left the country in the 70s, 80s, 90s…(because of war). Well, then you have a problem. The President won’t just stand around and watch his cabinet collapse because of incompetency, so he goes ahead and kicks out the incompetent people who also happen to be ethnic minorities…and installs Pashtuns in those positions. Well then now you have a government that looks favorist toward Pashtuns. And then other ethnic groups start clamoring that the government is again trying to further the oppressive Pashtun agenda, which the Taliban tried to do during the 90s (with backing from Pakistan). Incidentally, long beards and traditional long dress/burkas were not mandatory…until the Taliban came around. People blame the government for being corrupt and a Pashtun-favoritist government. The Taliban says the government is full of infidels and wants to replace it with their Pashtun Islamist horde. The government blames Pashtun Pakistan for terrorist violence. Minorities blame Pashtuns for terrorist violence, and for oppressive government of the Taliban, of Pakistan, etc….
So as you can see, you’ve got another complex history of ethnic conflict in a place where you thought all the people were just “camel jockeys.” No joke, but that’s the way hella people out there see it. I haven’t seen one camel here yet. But I have seen lots of different people with different histories here. And to solve their differences in ideas about government, religion, social norms, etc. will not be easy. No easier than it will be for Americans to understand Islam, for example. But the history here is much more complicated than I’ve just described it above. There have been whole series of books and lives devoted to the study of Afghanistan’s history, So it’s obvious that making “progress” is going to take a while.